Megan Nyre-Yu (Sandia National Laboratories), Elizabeth S. Morris (Sandia National Laboratories), Blake Moss (Sandia National Laboratories), Charles Smutz (Sandia National Laboratories), Michael R. Smith (Sandia National Laboratories)

MiTechnological advances relating to artificial intelligence (AI) and explainable AI (xAI) techniques are at a stage of development that requires better understanding of operational context. AI tools are primarily viewed as black boxes and some hesitation exists in employing them due to lack of trust and transparency. xAI technologies largely aim to overcome these issues to improve operational efficiency and effectiveness of operators, speeding up the process and allowing for more consistent and informed decision making from AI outputs. Such efforts require not only robust and reliable models but also relevant and understandable explanations to end users to successfully assist in achieving user goals, reducing bias, and improving trust in AI models. Cybersecurity operations settings represent one such context in which automation is vital for maintaining cyber defenses. AI models and xAI techniques were developed to aid analysts in identifying events and making decisions about flagged events (e.g. network attack). We instrumented the tools used for cybersecurity operations to unobtrusively collect data and evaluate the effectiveness of xAI tools. During a pilot study for deployment, we found that xAI tools, while intended to increase trust and improve efficiency, were not utilized heavily, nor did they improve analyst decision accuracy. Critical lessons were learned that impact the utility and adoptability of the technology, including consideration of end users, their workflows, their environments, and their propensity to trust xAI outputs.

View More Papers

An In-Depth Analysis on Adoption of Attack Mitigations in...

Ruotong Yu (Stevens Institute of Technology, University of Utah), Yuchen Zhang, Shan Huang (Stevens Institute of Technology)

Read More

Above and Beyond: Organizational Efforts to Complement U.S. Digital...

Rock Stevens (University of Maryland), Faris Bugra Kokulu (Arizona State University), Adam Doupé (Arizona State University), Michelle L. Mazurek (University of Maryland)

Read More

Vision: The Price Should Be Right: Exploring User Perspectives...

Jacob Hopkins (Texas A&M University - Corpus Christi), Carlos Rubio-Medrano (Texas A&M University - Corpus Christi), Cori Faklaris (University of North Carolina at Charlotte)

Read More

On Utility and Privacy in Synthetic Genomic Data

Bristena Oprisanu (UCL), Georgi Ganev (UCL & Hazy), Emiliano De Cristofaro (UCL)

Read More